U.S. Stocks Mixed; Dow Jones Falls 200+ Points

On September 5, particularly marked by disturbances in the stock market, the three major U.S. indices displayed contrasting performances, with the Dow Jones Industrial Average dipping by over 200 points. This decline was compounded by the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index recording its third consecutive day of losses. Preliminary private sector employment figures from ADP for August have intensified worries about a possible deceleration in the labor market, highlighting vulnerabilities in U.S. economic stability just days ahead of crucial employment reports.

At the close of trading, the Dow Jones Industrial Average plummeted by 219.22 points, settling at 40,755.75, which reflects a decline of approximately 0.54%. The S&P 500 followed suit, dipping by 16.66 points to close at 5,503.41, translating to a 0.30% decrease. Interestingly, the Nasdaq Composite Index managed to buck the trend, gaining 43.37 points to finish at 17,127.66, representing an increase of 0.25%.

According to a report released jointly by the ADP Research Institute and the Stanford Digital Economy Laboratory, the U.S. economy experienced an increase of just 99,000 jobs in August, significantly lower than the anticipated 140,000. The previous month's figure was also revised downward to 111,000—marking the lowest employment growth since January 2021 and reinforcing fears concerning the labor market’s health and resilience.

Advertisement

Nela Richardson, the chief economist at ADP, remarked on the ongoing shift, stating, "After two years of substantial growth, the slowdown in the labor market has resulted in hiring rates falling below normal levels. Wage growth, which saw a dramatic decline post-pandemic, is starting to stabilize." Despite the overall downturn, certain sectors like construction continue to show employment growth, showcasing some recovery signs ahead of the Federal Reserve's anticipated interest rate cuts. Meanwhile, warehousing sectors are ramping up recruitment efforts in light of the approaching holiday season.

Compounding the labor market narrative, the Department of Labor reported that for the week ending August 31, the number of individuals filing for first-time unemployment benefits was recorded at 227,000, slightly below the expected 230,000. Continuing claims also showed a similar trend with 1.838 million, again underneath the anticipated 1.869 million. Analysts note that the decrease in unemployment claims might help alleviate the market's anxiety over a further deterioration in employment numbers.

As pressure from inflation eases, employment statistics take center stage for the Federal Reserve. Market observers suggest that if the upcoming non-farm payroll figures depict a further softening in the U.S. employment landscape, it could compel the Federal Reserve to implement more substantial rate cuts.

A rise in the likelihood of a 50 basis point rate cut in September was observed following the release of ADP and unemployment data. The CME FedWatch Tool indicated that the odds of such a cut have now risen to 45%.

This week’s spotlight in the market is squarely on the upcoming August non-farm employment data. Currently, consensus forecasts suggest that the economy is expected to add 161,000 jobs, which would be an improvement over July’s meager growth of 114,000, with an anticipated slight dip in the unemployment rate to 4.2%.

Mary Daly from the San Francisco Federal Reserve articulated the necessity for rate cuts to sustain the health of the labor market, indicating that forthcoming data would ultimately shape the extent of any reductions.

Chris Larkin of Morgan Stanley expressed that, given the mixed signals from today’s data, tomorrow’s employment report is likely to provide investors with clearer insights into the state of the labor market. The difficulty remains in discerning whether the economy is experiencing an excessive slowdown and whether the Federal Reserve may be reacting too late to changing conditions.

Jonathan Cohn, head of U.S. interest rate strategy at Nomura Securities, acknowledged ongoing divisions within the market regarding the likelihood of a 25 versus a 50 basis point rate cut in September, asserting that the results from the non-farm payroll report would dictate the direction. He noted, "If unemployment rates and layoff figures hit certain thresholds, a 50 basis point cut is very much on the table."

In corporate highlights, C3.ai posted a robust performance in its first fiscal quarter for 2025, driven by surging enterprise demand for artificial intelligence. However, quarterly subscription revenues fell short of market expectations, leading to an 8.21% decrease in stock price, closing at $21.12 per share.

On the contrary, NIO managed to achieve record highs in both revenue and delivery volumes for Q2 of 2024, as its stock price surged by 14.39% to close at $4.85 per share.

In another significant market move, Tesla's stock rose by 4.90%, closing at $230.17 per share. Reports indicated that Tesla’s AI team plans to launch its Full Self-Driving (FSD) system in China and Europe during the first quarter of next year, pending regulatory approval, with insiders confirming the veracity of the information while awaiting regulatory clearance.

Turning to commodities, international oil prices saw a slight decline on the 5th. At the close of trading, light crude oil futures for October delivery settled down by five cents, to $69.15 per barrel, representing a diminutive drop of 0.07%.